| Article title | On the Issue of the Responsiveness Principle in Economic Court Proceedings in the Context of Universalization of the Court Process in Ukraine |
|---|---|
| Authors |
OLEKSII BRYNTSEV
|
| Magazine name | Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version) |
| Magazine number | 7 / 2018 |
| Pages | 34 - 46 |
| Annotation | In Ukraine, in the course of implementation of the court universalization policy, the principles (foundations) of economic, civil and administrative court proceedings have been unified. On the one part, this allowed eliminating a large number of hindrances to the access to justice ensuing from artificial differences which existed between the procedural codes. But on the other part, as a result of this policy, special types of the court process have lost some of their specific features, and in this connection – also opportunities and advantages. In particular, the fundamental branch-specific principle of the economic process – the principle of responsiveness (simplicity, economy) was actually abolished. The article aims at analyzing the reasons giving rise to the principle of responsiveness (simplicity, economy) in the economic process and the implications of its abolition within the framework of the court process universalization policy. The purpose of the article is to analyze why the principle of responsiveness (simplicity, efficiency) emerged in the economic process, and its role and the implications of abolition; and also to ascertain whether it is necessary to reinstate it. The author demonstrates that the principle of responsiveness is a specific natural and historically contingent feature of the procedure according to which legal disputes are resolved in the economic sector. It is established that the main reason why the principle of responsiveness was introduced into the court process was the need to resolve commercial disputes within the shortened timeline. Such a requirement stems from the fact that behind the parties to these disputes there are public interests of entire society and the State. The author proves that simplification of legal regulation of the court process is the key to its responsiveness and, hence, its efficiency. It is shown that the principle of responsiveness is implemented not only and not so much by setting short procedural deadlines, but also by a range of other procedural measures, which together make the process as simple, logical and predictable as possible. Ukraine has inherited the Soviet system of economic dispute resolution, which entirely complied with the principles of responsiveness. However, under the impact of various objective and subjective factors in the context of permanent reformation of the judicial system, the principle of responsiveness has been gradually withdrawn from the national economic process. The last step was the judicial reform of 2017, which in fact completely removed the principle of responsiveness from the economic procedural form. The author analyzes the main reformatory decisions which have formed the modern economic process in isolation from the basic principles of responsiveness, and comes to the conclusion that the tactical gain from such innovations is much less than the overall strategic loss in the form of complications and slowdown of the economic process on the whole
|
| Keywords | principle of responsiveness; court process; court process universalization; judicial reform; branch-specific principles of economic procedure |
| References |
List of legal documents
Legislation
5. Ukhvala Verkhovnoho Sudu [Ruling of the Supreme Court] vid 26 kvitnia 2018 r.
Bibliography
Authored books
|
| Electronic version | Download |